Switch Spaces on a Mac without disabling SIP
Search for a way to switch Spaces on a Mac and you will find advice to disable System Integrity Protection. For going to a Space, you do not need to. Here is what SIP is, what that advice is really about, and what you can use with it left on.
What SIP does
System Integrity Protection, SIP for short, is the macOS protection that stops other software from changing protected parts of the system. One thing it stops is injecting code into system processes such as the Dock, which does the work when you switch Spaces. Turning part of SIP off is a deliberate step: you restart into recovery and change it, and macOS then allows things it otherwise would not.
Why some tools ask for it
yabai is a tiling window manager, and a good one. Its README lists partly disabling SIP as optional, so that a scripting addition can be injected into the Dock for functions that need elevated privileges. Its wiki lists what that unlocks: moving, swapping, creating and destroying Spaces, removing window shadows, window transparency and animations, scratchpad windows, window layers, sticky windows, and picture in picture for any window. Its README also says shortcuts can be defined with skhd or other software.
So the advice to disable SIP is advice about those features. It is not a requirement for going to a Space.
What is hard about going to a Space
Asking macOS to go to a Space looks simple. There is a private call that does it, and it moves the display at once. The catch, which we measured, is that it leaves the Dock's own idea of the current Space stale. Mission Control then highlights the wrong Space, and a three finger swipe starts from the wrong place. The Dock has to be the one to perform the switch.
There are two ways to ask the Dock without injecting anything into it.
The first is Mission Control's Spaces Bar. It is an ordinary Accessibility interface with one button per Space, and pressing a button makes the Dock switch by itself. In our measurements that took about 684 milliseconds and worked 20 times out of 20.
The second posts the same kind of swipe your trackpad does, at a speed high enough that the Dock skips the animation. The technique comes from InstantSpaceSwitcher, an open source project under the MIT license. In our measurements a jump took about 69 milliseconds on an Apple silicon Mac running macOS 26, and in a separate test of five long jumps the active Space changed once each time, with none in between. The Leapdeck app uses this second route.
Both need the Accessibility permission, and neither touches SIP.
What you can use with SIP left on
- macOS itself. Control and an arrow key moves one Space at a time, Command and Tab goes by app, and Mission Control needs a click.
- InstantSpaceSwitcher. Free and open source. Its README says it does not require disabling SIP and asks for the Accessibility permission. It is unsigned, so macOS asks you to approve it the first time.
- SpaceJump. A paid app, $14.99 once with a 14 day trial. Its FAQ says it does not require disabling SIP, and that it needs the Accessibility permission.
- Leapdeck. A free Mac app with every hotkey, closed source, with SIP left on. It also sends the window in front to another Space, which we measured on macOS 27 with SIP on. Its Pro purchase adds names for Spaces, a Quick Switcher, a Shortcut that starts when a Space comes up, and more.
What the trade is
Leaving SIP on means you do not get the scripting addition's features. If you tile windows or script the creation of Spaces, you may want yabai and its SIP change. If you only want to get to a Space, you do not.
It also means relying on private macOS APIs, which Apple can change in any release. macOS 27 broke switching and menu bar clicks in Leapdeck, and version 0.2.1 fixed both. A tool that updates itself matters more here than usual.
Download Leapdeck for Mac, free.